Capital & Risk · Module 4 of 4
The Capital Return: Keep the Capital That Beats Its Cost, Return the Rest
Capital & Risk sized the cushion, deployed it, and stress-tested it. Now the last question: what to do with the $10M of excess capital left over, above the stress buffer, above every rule. You advise Keystone's board, and the room's instinct is unanimous: put it to work, grow the book. But the capital belongs to the shareholders, who require a return on it: the cost of equity, here 10%. Retaining a tranche of new lending creates value only if it earns MORE than that; capital that can't beat its cost is worth more returned (a buyback or dividend), where shareholders redeploy it at their required return. The new-business pipeline comes best-first in $2M tranches, each with its own return on capital. Where do you draw the line between retaining and returning? The empire is tempting: the biggest book, the highest total profit, and a blended return that may still clear the hurdle, so every headline says 'well done'. Score the split by value created, economic profit above the cost of equity, Σ (RAROC − cost of equity) × capital, not raw profit or book size. And is returning capital weakness, or can it create value? Split the $10M between retain and return, and watch the pipeline against the cost of equity. Then capital gets dearer: what happens to the right retention? Keep the capital that beats its cost of equity; return the rest. Module 4 of 4, the close of Capital & Risk: the whole life of a bank's capital: hold enough, deploy it well, stress it, and return what you can't profitably keep.