Wealth & Advice · Module 4 of 4
The Downturn Call
Three years ago this household's portfolio was set at $1,000k, half in equity, against a recorded tolerance of a $200k paper loss. It is $800k this morning, down exactly $200k. Nothing failed. The model was right, and that is what makes it hard: there is no error to find, nobody to correct, and the household is going to act anyway. At 8:40 they phoned and asked for all of it in cash, and when pressed they gave a number: they cannot lose another hundred thousand. Their adviser says hold, because it always comes back, and she is right about markets. It is also worth saying plainly that the bank earns more if they stay fully invested, so the revenue and the orthodoxy point the same way at the same client on the same morning. On the board is a vessel of everything still invested, a tray for what moves to cash, and a strain column showing what a further stress would take from the remainder, with a band across it at their number. You tip and pour, reversibly, until you instruct. The first move is measurement rather than persuasion: what does whatever stays invested expose them to, and how does that compare with what liquidating at the trough would cost them? Then ask how much to move, and how costly it is to be a little short of it or a little over. The adviser's answer is the disciplined one everybody in the room would defend, and the household's is their lawful instruction: how does each score? Does your own view of the recovery belong in the answer? Then the last turn: even the best trade may leave the plan short, because the trade was never the whole intervention. This is the capstone of Wealth & Advice.